Show summary Hide summary
Hailey Glassman says a surprise encounter with Martha Stewart at Manhattan’s Polo Bar ended with the lifestyle mogul allegedly leaving without settling her tab. The claim has stirred chatter among the Season 16 cast of The Real Housewives of New York City and adds a spicy anecdote to an already eventful new season.
Mystery at the Polo Bar: What Glassman Says
Glassman, one of RHONY’s newest faces, told Page Six she and several cast members met Martha Stewart at the upscale eatery ahead of filming. She alleges Stewart ordered food but walked out before paying.
Taylor Swift: are we over her now that her love story is complete?
Jaime King and Austin Sosa divorced after secret whirlwind marriage: split leaves them blindsided
Glassman described the moment as the group covering the check, suggesting the meal was quietly taken care of by those at the table.
Who Joined the Dinner
- Hailey Glassman
- Erin Lichy
- Jessel Taank
- Daisy Toye
- Erika Hammond
- Sai De Silva
The presence of multiple cast members turned the meal into a mini RHONY reunion. Representatives for Stewart had not returned requests for comment at the time of the report.
Martha Stewart’s Cameos on RHONY Season 16
Although Glassman said she never taped scenes with Stewart, the household-name has slipped into the season in several short appearances.
Daisy Toye has a direct link to Stewart. Toye works as Stewart’s makeup artist, which explains why Stewart shows up in Toye’s storyline.
A memorable first scene
Toye’s opening scene features Stewart visiting her rent-controlled apartment for makeup. The two chat, and Stewart shares a personal anecdote tied to a historical tragedy.
The JFK Jr. Story That Made the Cut
In the episode, Stewart recalls speaking to John F. Kennedy Jr. in the days before his fatal plane crash. She says he called her for advice about his magazine project, and they met for dinner that week.
Stewart also told the cast she had suggested he consider having a co-pilot for a trip he later took with family. The anecdote plays as a somber flashback amid the lighter reality-TV moments.
How Stewart Interacts with Cast Members Off Camera
Beyond cameos, Stewart appears as an off-screen advisor to some cast members. She offers cooking tips to Toye and has been seen meeting her for meals in other episodes.
The dynamic blends mentorship and celebrity friendship, giving the show a crossover appeal to Stewart’s fans.
Production Notes and Where to Watch
- Season: 16 of The Real Housewives of New York City
- Air time: Tuesday nights at 8 p.m. ET
- Streaming: New episodes available next day on Peacock
Fans curious about Stewart’s brief moments and the Polo Bar allegation can catch the episodes during their weekly broadcast or stream them on the platform the following day.
