Show summary Hide summary
Pittsburgh’s offense has sputtered all season, and the fallout of a high-profile trade is drawing fresh scrutiny. After parting ways with wide receiver George Pickens and adding veteran Aaron Rodgers, the Steelers sit at 6-5 and have failed to find consistent rhythm on offense.
Offensive woes persist despite star additions
The numbers highlight a unit that has underperformed. Pittsburgh ranks near the bottom in yards per game and its aerial attack has produced just 2,279 passing yards to date. Meanwhile, the defense has surrendered more than 3,000 yards through the air, adding pressure to an uneven roster.
Jets lock up young star with massive 4-year contract
James Burrows dead at 85: Will & Grace director and Cheers co-creator
Fans and analysts point to several reasons for the stagnation:
- Loss of explosive playmakers after offseason moves.
- Inconsistent quarterback play and playcalling.
- Penalties and self-inflicted mistakes that stall drives.
How the Pickens trade changed the landscape
Pittsburgh moved Pickens to Dallas in May in a deal that returned a third-round draft pick. The swap has become a focal point as Pickens thrives with his new team.
Production gap: Pickens has already surpassed 1,000 receiving yards this season. His former teammates, collectively, have not matched his output. That contrast fuels questions about value received in the trade.
- George Pickens: 1,054 receiving yards (2025 season)
- Remaining Steelers WRs (combined): 1,009 receiving yards
- Return to Steelers: a single third-round pick
From discipline concerns to a fresh start in Dallas
Pickens’ time in Pittsburgh included episodes that tested team patience. Multiple unsportsmanlike penalties late in the 2024 season drew criticism and prompted stern words from the coaching staff.
Coaches and teammates suggested he needed to mature and curb emotional outbursts. Since joining Dallas, Pickens appears to have settled into a role with fewer off-field distractions and a clearer on-field purpose.
Immediate impact with the Cowboys
In a key win over Philadelphia, Pickens caught nine passes for 146 yards and a touchdown. He now stands at 67 receptions, 1,054 yards and eight touchdowns for the season, numbers that underline his influence on Dallas’ offense.
Contract talks and wider implications
Discussions about a long-term deal between Pickens and the Cowboys are reportedly underway. If a new contract materializes, Dallas could lock down its top playmaker for years.
For Pittsburgh, the trade and the team’s offensive struggles raise larger questions about roster construction and where the franchise goes next. Missing the playoffs would likely accelerate a rebuild and deepen scrutiny of front-office decisions.
What to watch next
- Whether Pickens signs a long-term contract in Dallas.
- How Pittsburgh adjusts its receiving corps and offensive game plan.
- Impact of continued offensive struggles on Mike Tomlin’s roster moves.
- Rodgers’ performance and how it influences the Steelers’ immediate direction.
